A pet peeve of mine regarding ‘poor acting’

October 6, 2008 9:17 am

Why do people blame actors for terrible acting? Usually, it’s the writer who has poorly written a scene.

It’s hard to be cool when you’re delivering some of the worst dialog ever. It’s like Star Wars fans who blame Anakin or Jar Jar for wrecking what otherwise could have been okay movies. That’s insane. Because first of all, those movies had no redeeming qualities at all anyway, and those characters were awful because the written poorly.

It’s true, some actors have delivered terrible lines and made them almost non-cringeworthy, but those are only situations where the dialog isn’t important.

A good example is Yakuza (the first game), lots of people blame the voice acting, but it was actually pretty good acting, but they were just saying really ridiculous dialog. It worked for me because the game was ridiculous anyway. The fact there were Japanese street punks and yakuza that were talking like they were straight out of the Staten Island in the mid-80s just made it more awesome.

In short, don’t blame the actors as much as the writers (in most cases).

2 Responses to “A pet peeve of mine regarding ‘poor acting’”

Erin wrote a comment on October 9, 2008

^__^ This is hardly controversial! I think you’ve made really good points. Even Liam Neeson had a hard time looking cool saying things like “There’s always a bigger fish!”

Although I may just throw the idea out there that some people seem to have a bit more sparkle when delivering any sort of line, or just standing on screen. Of course, this could be a matter of personal taste, and maybe tonnes of people think (an actor I don’t much care for; can’t think of any examples at the moment) is extremely charismatic and a wonderful actor.

But I ENTIRELY agree that a good script is one of the most important components of a good movie/TV show/game/&c. It’s pretty hard for even mediocre actors to ruin a good script.

Next time I encounter ‘poor acting,’ I am definitely going to pay attention to whether it’s the acting, or actually what’s being said!

admin wrote a comment on October 9, 2008

That’s so true, I’ve never seen Anthony Hopkins be bad in anything.

Care to comment?